Food of the Seventies, Pop Tarts: Peanut Butter Buffalos

I also have food pages for the 80s and 90s.

Picture Gallery

Loading images, if this message doesn't go away you may need to enable javascript in order to see pictures
No images

No pictures available yet!

 Submit a picture 

A Pop Tart without icing that had a peanutbutter filling, chocolate dough outside with a simple outline type design of a buffalo imprinted on the topside. They also made chocolate elephants too but the peanutbutter buffalos were the best. Last seen and tasted in the early 70's.... so sad.
Links for more info

The following are links about Pop Tarts: Peanut Butter Buffalos you may find interesting. Also check out the other pages.

  • No links have been submitted for this page yet.

Submit a link to more information about Pop Tarts: Peanut Butter Buffalos

User Stories and Comments

The following are comments left about Pop Tarts: Peanut Butter Buffalos from site visitors such as yourself. They are not spell checked or reviewed for accuracy.

Debbie - July 12, 2008 - Report this comment
I loved the chocolate elephant ones and the cinnamon lion ones. I would love to be able to get them again.
ellen behrends - September 14, 2008 - Report this comment
Yes!!! The peanut butter buffalos were the best!!! They also made Tutti Fruiti Owls. POST made this brand of "Pop Tarts
june owens - June 23, 2009 - Report this comment
I am so glad someone else remembers peanutbutter buffalos, my family did not remember and i started to think I was loosing my mind and I LOVED peanut butterbuffalos
Tom Planchet - August 09, 2010 - Report this comment
The peanut butter buffaloes were the best 'pop tart' of all time. I can't believe no one has re-created them. The chocolate and cinnamon were great too. If I could only have one again. What memories from my youth.
Reggie Dunlop - October 22, 2010 - Report this comment
It's funny, but my whole life I have remembered these things like I ate one yesterday. I believe that they were, quite simply, the most delicious thing I've ever eaten---and I just turned 50 this year!!! I think of them often, as I would a childhood best friend who moved away.
Karen Klein - March 17, 2011 - Report this comment
I mourn the loss of Peanut Butter Buffaloes, Tutti Frutti Owl, Chocolate Elephants and Berry Bears! Oh, I miss them!
Janice Gibson - September 14, 2011 - Report this comment
I didn't think I would EVER find anyone that remembered the Chocolate Elephants! They were my favorite! I still have the dart board with all the pop tart animals on it that you got by sending in the box tops... does anyone else still have theirs? Fun memories...
Lyn - August 24, 2012 - Report this comment
I loved chocolate elephants. I'm glad other people remember them!
scooter - December 18, 2012 - Report this comment
If I remember correctly, the Chocolate Elephant product was from Post, the competitor to Kelloggs. The actual product was something like "Post Tostems". From there, you could get the variety of Flavors. AND.....hands down, the ese were so much better than what is offered today.
Ian - March 08, 2013 - Report this comment
I loved those pop tarts. My earliest childhood breakfast memories are of my mom giving us those as part of our breakfast. I searched google for the sole purpose of seeing if anyone remembered them. Chocolate Elephant and Tootie Fruity Owl were my favorites.
kbweinberg - July 04, 2013 - Report this comment
I found a box of peanut butter filled chocolate pop tarts at Kroger this week. close in flavor.
Tari from MO - August 01, 2014 - Report this comment
Just ate the peanut butter and choc pop tart. I've looked these up before and couldn't find any info on them and NO one I Know remembers the pop tarts with animals on them . I remember ratting a bunch of the peanut butter ones😊
Rob Lambert - August 04, 2014 - Report this comment
The Post animal-shaped toaster pastries were discontinued by 1974. At the time, Kellogg's had Milton the Toaster as a mascot, and only offered. basically, the same flavors Pop Tarts started with in 1964. Sales of the animal tarts were probably not strong enough for them to last more than a year and a half. Since it was a Post product, fans can try appealing to Kraft to bring them back.
Chinese Ark - July 20, 2016 - Report this comment
I definitely remember Peanut Butter Buffaloes and Chocolate Elephants, and I think there might have a cinnamon one too (bears maybe?)
Barb - November 17, 2016 - Report this comment
The best pop tarts ever! I miss them.

Submit a story or info about Pop Tarts: Peanut Butter Buffalos